My Favourite NYC Restaurants: Must-Try Spots for Your New York Visit
- Karli Gibson
- May 18, 2025
- 5 min read
New York City isn't just home to towering skyscrapers and people who walk at Olympic speeds – it's also where I've had some truly incredible meals! After eating my way across the city (or trying to in 5 days), I've put together this list of my absolute favourite spots. From pizza joints that made me consider moving, to taco spots that have ruined all other tacos for me forever, these are the restaurants I enthusiastically dragged all of my friends to. These aren't just places to eat – they're the spots where I've created some of my favourite NYC memories. Consider this your personal food tour from a girl who will plan her whole trip around where we eat.
Bagels: A New York Staple
No culinary journey through New York City is complete without indulging in its iconic bagels. Renowned for their chewy texture and glossy crust, New York bagels are a beloved breakfast staple that reflects the city's rich cultural tapestry. From classic plain bagels to innovative flavour combinations, New York offers a vibrant selection of bagel shops, each with its own twist on this timeless treat.
Leon Bagels is famous for its authentic New York-style bagels, freshly made to achieve the perfect balance of chewiness and flavour. With a wide variety of toppings, spreads, and hearty sandwiches, it caters to all tastes while providing a warm and inviting atmosphere. Conveniently located in the heart of NYC, it is a must-visit for any bagel lover. Plus I'm obsessed with their branding.
Thompkins Square Bagels in NYC is renowned for its freshly baked bagels that boast a perfect chewy texture. Patrons appreciate the wide variety of flavours and toppings, making it a go-to spot for breakfast or a quick snack. The friendly atmosphere and quick service add to its charm, ensuring that customers keep coming back for more.
Liberty Bagels is a popular bagel shop known for its fresh, hand-rolled bagels made daily. They offer a wide variety of flavours and toppings, catering to both traditional and adventurous tastes. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, it's a favourite spot for locals and visitors alike to enjoy a delicious breakfast or snack.
Brooklyn Bagels are renowned for their unique, chewy texture and rich flavour, often achieved through a traditional boiling process before baking. These bagels are typically made with high-quality ingredients, resulting in a delightful crust and a soft, airy interior. Whether enjoyed plain or topped with a variety of spreads and fillings, Brooklyn Bagels have become a beloved staple in New York's culinary landscape.
Coffee and Brunch
Coffee and brunch in NYC combine delightful flavours and experiences for every palate. Artisanal coffee shops serve expertly brewed drinks, while brunch spots offer creative spins on classic dishes. Neighbourhoods like the Lower East and West Side have hidden gems serving everything from avocado toast to decadent pancakes, all complemented by rich coffee. Whether you seek a cozy café or a lively eatery, NYC's brunch scene has something for everyone.
Ralphs Coffee - An iconic local staple, Ralphs offers a perfect retreat for coffee lovers. Enjoy expertly brewed beverages made from the finest beans, all while soaking in the charm of this beloved neighbourhood spot.
Devocion Coffee is renowned for its commitment to freshness, sourcing beans directly from Colombia and roasting them on-site. The vibrant atmosphere, adorned with lush greenery, creates a unique space for coffee lovers to enjoy expertly crafted brews.
Maman is a charming café that blends French and American influences, offering a delightful menu of artisanal pastries and specialty coffees. Its cozy, rustic decor invites patrons to relax and savour each sip while indulging in homemade treats.
If coffee isn't your beverage of choice, consider visiting the charming Cha Cha Matcha, a delightful spot that can be found throughout the city. (There)
Clinton St. Baking in Red Hook is another standout. With a loyal following, this BBQ spot serves mouthwatering brisket and pork ribs that top lists of the city’s best. Their meat is smoked for several hours, making it tender and packed with flavor. A common customer statement is that just a couple of bites will leave your taste buds wanting more.
Bubby's in Red Hook is another standout. With a loyal following, this BBQ spot serves mouthwatering brisket and pork ribs that top lists of the city’s best. Their meat is smoked for several hours, making it tender and packed with flavor. A common customer statement is that just a couple of bites will leave your taste buds wanting more.
Pizza
Looking for a late night slice? NYC pizza is a beloved culinary staple featuring a thin, sturdy crust, mozzarella cheese, and simple tomato sauce. Famous spots like Joe's Pizza, Di Fara Pizza, and Prince Street Pizza highlight the city's diverse pizza culture, offering traditional slices, Sicilian, and Grandma styles. Whether by the slice or whole, NYC pizza is an essential New York experience.
Among my top choices are Joe's and Prince Street, both of which offer exceptional flavours and unique styles. I've also heard great things about L'industrie, but unfortunately, we didn't have the opportunity to try it this time!
Dinner
We love a share plate and NYC delivers. For dinner in NYC, we indulged in a delightful array of share plates at Gurume in Hell's Kitchen, where the flavours are as vibrant as the atmosphere. We savoured their signature tuna tartare, beautifully presented with avocado and a zesty citrus dressing, alongside crispy tempura vegetables that added a satisfying crunch. You also must try the Black Sesame Bread pudding, its stunning!
C as in Charlie offered a cozy setting with inventive dishes that kept us coming back for more. The 99-cent sweet tea is a delightful beverage, and its affordability combined with its classic flavor has made it a beloved choice for many, particularly within Southern cuisine. Additionally, their Popcorn Chicken, adorned with a delicious gochujang glaze and served in an adorable popcorn-style presentation, is the best I've ever tasted.
At Catch, we enjoyed a lively and modern atmosphere. The lobster mac and cheese was rich and creamy and its something I wish I could have all the time. While the Crispy Shrimp, seasoned and cooked just right, provided a satisfying crunch. The crispy brussel sprouts added a nice contrast, making for a well-rounded dining experience.
Lastly, Little Ruby's in Soho offered a delightful atmosphere for comfort food that truly felt like home. We savored their delectable shrimp pasta, accompanied by an irresistible serving of crispy Brussels sprouts.
Looking for something a little more low-key? Have a group that can't agree on a dinner spot? Try the Chelsea Market and check out Los Tacos No.1. Featuring traditional Mexican recipes made with fresh ingredients and a variety of options from carne asada to vegetarian dishes. The quick service and casual vibe make it perfect for those on the go or looking to socialize over good food.
Google My Maps
Looking for a visual way to organize your travels? Google My Maps lets you create custom itineraries with personalized icons to mark everywhere you've visited, places still on your wishlist, and all your must-see spots in between.
Final Thoughts
New York City is brimming with culinary treasures waiting to be uncovered. From the lively East Village to the cozy Bronx, adventurous Brooklyn, and the diverse flavours of Queens, each neighbourhood offers unique dining experiences that reflect the city’s rich diversity.
Whether you're a passionate foodie or simply looking for a satisfying meal, taking the time to explore these hidden culinary gems will reward you with unforgettable tastes and experiences. Be ready for a delicious journey that leaves you with lasting memories. Happy dining!
Comments